Joyce Man  in ADDA OPINION

In the night leading up to September 1 news started coming in that hundreds of asylum seekers were making their way via the Balkan route through Hungary and Austria to Munich — a popular stop in Germany, a top destination in Europe for those seeking refuge.

By early morning, the Munich police had announced that 590 had arrived.

Screenshot 2019-04-21 at 1.50.12 AM.png

Indeed by 11 a.m. crowds were streaming in on platforms 11 to 13 where trains from Keleti station in Budapest and Vienna, Austria, stopped. They were escorted by the police in a calm, orderly manner to receive food and water at a square outside the station before lining up to board buses to get registered by the authorities.


Among the passengers were exhausted elderly women and families with young children. Many said they had come from Iraq or Syria over the now well-known and increasingly popular route via Turkey, Greece, Macedonia, Serbia, Austria and Hungary. Many also reported paying upwards of €1,200 each to make the water crossing from Turkey to Greece, and walking the rest of the way.


The overcrowding puts an obvious strain on the city’s resources. Here, a young boy runs across one of many unrepaired roads near a Mandaluyong City slum.


Dozens of police and train security personnel lined up waiting for the hundreds of people that came each time a train arrived from Austria or Hungary, every half hour to one hour. Each time, they would escort them to the square and funnel them into a side hall to receive food, water and basic necessities, in a procedure that appeared practiced and well-organized.


Instead of the cold, high-security atmosphere that some media had predicted, scenes at the station remained calm and even warmed up as some officers helped the new arrivals and played with the children.


As word got out, officials, residents and politicians voiced worries about how the state was going to accommodate them. But many more residents showed up to welcome the asylum seekers, bringing donations to the hall, where supplies were temporarily housed.

Screenshot 2019-04-21 at 1.51.15 AM.png

Many who came with donations had to be turned away, like Vanessa Blind and Mickel Pentsch, who had brought unsold organic bread.

During the day, Hungarian officials stopped migrants from boarding westbound trains. As of nightfall, the stream in Munich slowed. Though crowds continued to arrive as commuters headed home from work, the chaos that some predicted did not materialize.

#Asylum seekers continue to stream into #Munich as commuters stream out at day end. Still no sign of chaos. #Refugees

— Joyce Man (@joyciemannie) September 1, 2015

  • Twitter - White Circle
  • Instagram - White Circle
  • Facebook - White Circle
  • LinkedIn - White Circle
  • SoundCloud - White Circle

© 2023 Justice Adda, Proudly created with

Justice Adda was a part of the Cambridge Social Ventures Programme in the Cambridge Centre for Social Innovation at Cambridge Judge Business School 2016-17.